Where the Hope Diamond and other famous stones came from
The Hope, the Koh-i-noor and the Cullinan: where three famous diamonds began, how they traveled, and which parts of their stories are still unsettled.
On this page
Two diamonds from one corner of India, one from a mine wall
Two famous diamonds, the Hope and the Koh-i-noor, are tied to the same old mining region of India, called Golconda 1. The third big name here, the Cullinan, was pried out of a South African mine wall in January 1905 and later reached England by parcel post 6.
Each story also runs through a royal owner: Louis XIV for the Hope, Queen Victoria for the Koh-i-noor and Edward VII for the Cullinan 257.
The Hope: a blue stone with a gap in its story
The Hope sat underground for more than a billion years before it became famous 2. The Smithsonian's telling picks up in 1668, when a French traveler and gem merchant, Jean Baptiste Tavernier, sold a blue diamond of 112 3/16 carats to King Louis XIV 2. Tavernier was cagey about the source and offered only the word India 2. A history of the region from the gem institute GIA goes further and lists the Hope among the Golconda stones, from an area now known as Hyderabad 1.
Louis XIV had it recut for the crown jewels, and thieves took it in 1792 during the riots of the French Revolution 2. In 1812 a stone turned up in England at 45.52 carats, the shape and size the Hope has today 2.
Was it the same diamond? A lead cast of the stolen French Blue, found in a museum mineral collection in Paris, gave researchers a way to test the idea 3. Their computer models show the Hope could have been recut from it 3. The catalog entry for that cast also hints that Henry Philip Hope may have held the French Blue after the theft and before the recut 3. The Smithsonian's account has this London banker buying the stone in 1830, with his name staying on it ever since 2. Those two versions sit a little awkwardly together, and that gap is part of the fun.
The Hope family let the diamond go in 1901, and some of the owners who followed enjoyed spreading talk of a curse 2. The run of owners ended in 1958, when the New York jeweler Harry Winston handed it to the Smithsonian, where the public can see it now 2.
Why that blue may begin with seawater
GIA uses the Hope as its showcase for type IIb, a rare group of diamonds with boron in the crystal, which can turn them blue 4. That is odd, because boron gathers near the surface of the planet and is very scarce in the mantle, the deep layer where diamonds grow 4.
A paper in Nature in August 2018 offered an answer after examining 46 of these stones sent to GIA 4. Tiny minerals trapped inside them pointed to growth at 410 to 660 km down or deeper, about four times farther than most diamonds 4. The proposal goes like this: seawater leaves boron in the ocean floor, moving plates drag that rock down, and deep heat and pressure release a boron-rich fluid that sets off diamond growth 4. The authors say the boron may have come from ancient oceans, so this is a proposed model and not a closed case, and GIA's summary does not list the Hope among the 46 4.
The Koh-i-noor: a nickname and a superstition
It is not known exactly when the Koh-i-noor was found, though GIA says it is likely from Golconda 5. The memoirs of Babur, the first Mughal emperor of India, mention a big diamond said to be worth half of what the whole world spent in a day, and that stone is thought to be this one 5. It moved between Indian and Persian rulers for centuries 5. The story goes that Nader Shah gave it its name in 1739 on first seeing it, calling out the words for mountain of light 5.
Queen Victoria acquired it in 1849 through the Last Treaty of Lahore, after the British annexation of the Punjab 5. It arrived in England in 1850, badly cut and set in an armlet, and a recut in 1852 took off a lot of weight, leaving the 105.60 carats it has now 5. Legend says it brings bad luck to any man who wears it, so since it came into British hands the only wearers have been queens and queens consort 5. It now sits in a crown on display in the Tower of London 5.
The Cullinan: a decoy ship and a broken knife
The Cullinan weighed 3,106.75 carats, and a 2014 account in EARTH Magazine still ranked it as the largest gem-quality rough diamond ever found 6. It came from the Premier Mine, on land Thomas Cullinan had bought just over two years earlier 6. Accounts of the discovery differ, down to the exact day, but the usual version has mine manager Frederick Wells spotting, or being alerted by a worker to, something shiny in the pit wall 6. Some at the mine doubted it was real, and one worker supposedly threw it out of the office window 6.
Shipping it called for a trick. A steamship left with a guarded replica in its safe, while the real stone went to London as an ordinary-looking parcel, and both got there 6.
In 1907 the Transvaal government bought the diamond 6. It went to King Edward VII as a birthday gift, and he had it cut up 7. Joseph Asscher set a blade in a groove in the stone and struck it, and the blade broke with the diamond untouched, so he fitted a second, larger one 6. The popular tale that he fainted when the stone finally split is disputed 6. The result was nine large diamonds and 96 small brilliants 7, with nearly two-thirds of the rough lost along the way 6. The two largest are Cullinan I, in the Sovereign's Sceptre, and Cullinan II, in the Imperial State Crown 7.
Worth watching: the Hope's owners, animated
Smithsonian Channel's "The Many Owners of the Hope Diamond" is an animated look at the stone's history, from its series Mystery of the Hope Diamond. It fits here because the list of owners is the hardest part of this story to keep straight.
Where to go next
The Koh-i-noor is a modified oval, and our oval diamond price page shows how that shape is listed by carat 5. Cullinan II is a cushion cut, one of the shapes on our fancy shape price page 7. And if you are curious how mined stones compare with ones made in a lab, our guide to lab-grown vs natural diamonds sets them side by side.
Sources
- Golconda Diamonds: Exploring the Legendary Source of Famous Gems
- A Gem of a Story: The Hope Diamond
- The French Blue and the Hope: New Data from the Discovery of a Historical Lead Cast
- Where Do Blue Diamonds Come From?
- The Koh-i-Noor Diamond: History and Significance
- January 26, 1905: The world's largest gem-quality diamond is unearthed
- The Story of Famous Diamonds: Cullinan II
Keep reading
We may be paid when you buy through links on this page. How we make money